Free Consultations 24/7
Home > Blog > The Unfairness ...
Imagine this. Your elderly mother has a stroke that leaves her partially paralyzed. The hospital is about to release her and a decision needs to be made about her ongoing care. After weighing the options, your family decides to place her in a nursing home. You accompany her there and review the admission papers on her behalf. Included among them is a document entitled “Resident and Facility Arbitration Agreement.” Distraught over your mother’s condition, you read through the papers quickly and sign.
Then the unthinkable happens. Due to the nursing home’s neglect, your mother suffers a bedsore that leads to amputation of a limb. When you file a lawsuit, the nursing home moves to enforce the arbitration agreement. Your attorney, knowing that lawsuits are superior to arbitration for claims of this nature, opposes the motion. The court, however, grants the motion, and you are forced to arbitrate the claim.
This scenario and others like it happen with increasing frequency as “pre-dispute” nursing home arbitration agreements have become the industry norm. Many states, like Ohio, have legislation designed to mitigate the unfairness of these agreements, but they do so by half-measures, such as requiring the agreement to specify that signing it is not a condition of admission or that, by signing the agreement, the patient is giving up her right to a jury trial.
But these statutes do not address the fundamental problem. Why should the patient or her family be pressured to sign an arbitration agreement before a dispute has arisen -- particularly when the agreement is presented at such an emotionally charged time as upon admission to a nursing home?
The United States Congress is currently considering legislation that would make pre-dispute nursing home arbitration agreements illegal. This legislation, called the “Fairness in Nursing Home Arbitration Act,” would prohibit nursing homes from enforcing pre-dispute arbitration agreements. The bill would not ban post-dispute arbitration agreements, but would permit the parties to choose arbitration if the choice is made after a controversy exists.
Unless this legislation is passed, nursing homes will continue to include pre-dispute arbitration agreements in their admission packets, and unwary patients and their families will continue to sign away their rights.
Although arguments can be made to avoid enforcing these agreements, they are often met with resistance in the Ohio courts. Frequently patients’ lawyers argue that the arbitration agreement is “unconscionable” based on the circumstances at the time of the patient’s admission, and the fact that the agreement forces the patient to give up certain rights he or she would have if the claim were litigated in the judicial system.
If you have questions regarding Nursing Home Arbitration Agreements contact an experienced nursing home attorney at Nurenberg Paris.
Apr
22, 2024
Medical malpractice claims are often difficult to win, and the difference between strong claims and weak claims is evidence, especially medical records. If you believe you’re a victim of medical malpractice, your medical records will be vital for building your case against the doctor, hospital, or clinic that you believe harmed you. These documents not […]
18, 2024
Injuries caused by auto accidents are painful, expensive, and can even be life-altering. When victims survive car accidents, they want to believe that the worst is over. But for some, the medical and financial consequences are just beginning. Shock is not just a term for being surprised or upset. It is an actual medical condition […]
15, 2024
The widespread availability of fast internet access and camera-equipped laptops, desktops, tablets, and smartphones mean that telemedicine and virtual doctor appointments are more convenient, personal, and effective than ever before. These types of visits became more and more common during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, and for many patients, they have continued to be […]
08, 2024
One of the most important aspects of being a doctor is accurately diagnosing patients with the diseases or illnesses they suffer from. Accurately diagnosing patients gives doctors a chance to come up with treatment plans to manage their patients’ symptoms and help them get better, including prescribing medications, recommending surgery, and creating lifestyle modifications. However, […]
01, 2024
When a bad outcome happens in medicine, whether it’s after a doctor prescribes a prescription drug or a surgeon completes an operation, it’s common for patients to wonder if they’re victims of medical malpractice. However, proving medical malpractice is notoriously difficult. That’s why many Ohio medical malpractice lawyers rely on the testimony of expert witnesses. […]
Accessibility Tools