Verdict & Settlement Wins

Personal Injury Lawyers with Experience

Thomas Mester Jonathan D. Mester
Amount: $3,500,000
Plaintiff's Counsel: Thomas Mester, Jonathan D. Mester

Failure to Diagnose Shunt Malfunction Resulting in Quadriplegia Settles for $3.5 Million

Medical Malpractice Plaintiff was born on September 8, 1986. Shortly after her birth, she suffered from bacterial meningitis which resulted in permanent hearing loss. Also associated with the bacterial meningitis, was hydrocephalus, which is essentially water in the brain. The hydrocephalus was treated with a shunt which periodically malfunctioned and she had multiple shunt replacements.

On May 11, 2000, she presented to the emergency room with headaches, sleeping a lot, difficultly walking, not eating, and had not been to school for several days. The emergency room physician suspected hydrocephalus and ordered a CT scan of the brain. The radiologist orally and later in writing reported to the physician that the ventricles were significantly larger than in January of that year. The emergency room physician discharged the patient with a diagnosis of sinus cephalgia and hydrocephalus. The standard of care in such a situation was for the emergency room physician to either admit the patient or contact a neurosurgeon as the treatment decision would be neurosurgical, i.e., replacement of the shunt. This was not done. Two days later, plaintiff went to a different facility where a shunt malfunction was diagnosed and was then sent to a full service children’s hospital for care. Unfortunately, in the process, she suffered a herniation of the brain resulting in quadriplegia. Her condition is permanent and she will need care for the rest of her life.

This matter was settled in a mediation prior to trial in the amount of $3.5 million.
See More Verdicts

Free Initial Consultation


Cleveland, OH

1370 Ontario Street, Suite 100
Cleveland, Ohio 44113

Phone: (216) 621-2300
Toll Free: (888) 900-6075

Fax: (216) 771-2242

Independence, OH

6100 Oak Tree Boulevard
Suite 200
(Middle of three buildings)
Independence, Ohio 44131

Toll Free: (888) 900-6075

Fax: (216) 771-2242

Cincinnati, OH

PNC Center
201 E. Fifth Street
19th Floor
Cincinnati, Ohio 45202

Toll Free: (888)900-6075

Columbus, OH

Galleria at PNC Plaza
20 S Third Street
Suite 210
Columbus, Ohio 43215

Toll Free: (888) 900-6075

Dayton, OH

Beavercreek Greene Town Center
70 Birch Alley
Suite 240, Building B
Beavercreek, Ohio 45440

Toll Free: (888) 900-6075

Toledo, OH

1715 Indian Wood Circle, Suite 200
Maumee, Ohio, 43537

Toll Free: (888) 900-6075